About Perth Mint Bullion Blog

You are invited to engage with senior representatives of The Perth Mint, including CEO Ed Harbuz, on The Perth Mint Bullion Blog. Use the comments section to post your views and/or questions in response to our regular articles, and join a vibrant community of people who share an interest in superb quality gold and silver bullion bars and coins.

PLEASE READ
Our Blog Disclaimer.

Our Comments Policy.
Our Copyright Policy.

Perth Mint Bullion BlogSubscribe
« Back to full list

Perth Mint Depository Fear Index

Topics [ unallocated depository store silver allocated store gold ]

EDUCATION

The Perth Mint has long advocated a staged approach to storing precious metals:

1. While the world environment is benign, hold unallocated, saving on ongoing storage costs and fabrication charges.
2. When the world environment becomes uncertain and risky, convert to allocated if you personally are concerned.
3. When the world is at a crisis point, take delivery.

This approach can save significant amounts of money as it may be some time between stage 1 and 2. Clients who do not feel they can judge the shift from stage 1 to 2, or feel it may be sudden and unpredictable, opt for allocated as they are using precious metals as "insurance" and see the storage fees as the cost of that insurance.

Changes in the percentage of metal held in allocated form can therefore indicate a change in clients’ perception of uncertainty and risk – a “fear index”. The chart below graphs that percentage since mid-1999, when the gold price bottomed. The percentage includes gold, silver and platinum together to give an aggregate view.



The declining percentage up to 2008 reflects clients opting to put more dollars into unallocated storage over allocated. It should come as no surprise to see the percentage start to increase in 2008 as the global financial crisis took hold. Recently, the percentage has stabilised around 15%, but we would not be surprised to see it rise.

In respect of stage three – taking delivery – this has always been insignificant and we haven’t seen any change in collection rates, indicating that while we are seeing a shift to allocated, our clients are “alert, but not alarmed” (to borrow the catchphrase from the Australian Government advertising campaign).

It is worth noting that in mid-1999 Depository only held $100 million worth of metal (valued at today’s dollars) compared to $3.5 billion today, which is a fear index in itself.

Blog Disclaimer, Comments Policy, Copyright Policy

Blog DisclaimerComments PolicyCopyright Policy

Comment »

12 Comments

  • May 12 2011

    rob brown says:


    This article does not explain "Why"  someone might switch to allocated from unallocated if the world environment becomes uncertain and risky and they are personally concerned about this.

    Also, since May 1st unallocated holding is no longer available at the Perth Mint, it has been replaced with a pool allocated option. Does the same scenario still hold?
  • May 13 2011

    Jeff says:

    Has the premium for PM silver bullion bars across all range (10oz, 20oz, 1kg and 100oz) gone up most recently?

    How much above spot respectively are they now?  Thanks.
  • May 13 2011

    Bron Suchecki says:

    Rob,
     
    The reason people switch to allocated is that it is an interim step to taking delivery. They feel that the economic situation is deteriorating to the point where it might tip into a societal breakdown, in which case they would want to take personal possession of their metal, often with the intention of using as a barter currency. Having their metal in allocated form makes it available for collection a lot quicker than converting unallocated.

    Bron
  • May 13 2011

    Ron Currie says:

    Hi Jeff

    Premiums for silver bars were increased marginally at the end of February in response to increased manufacturing costs and higher silver handling prices (freight etc). We've always reserved the right to amend premiuns - both up and down - depending on the market situation.

    Regards

    Ron Currie
  • May 13 2011

    Louis Nardozi says:

    Stage 3 has always been insignificant...

    Because we don't make any money off it.
    Because you can't find a hiding place for something small enough that $500,000 worth will fit inside a hat.
    Because we cannot track your profits and report them to the government like we can with any other asset.
  • May 15 2011

    TonyC says:

    Hey Louis,

    And I thought I was a cynic!
  • June 18 2012

    Adrian Coman says:

    Hi Bron,

    Do you have an update for this index? I'm curios also if you see any change in the collection rates.

    Thanks,
    Adrian
  • June 18 2012

    Bron Suchecki says:

    Adrian,



    I had a look at the chart recently and it has slightly trended upward to 16%, so no real change. Collection rates are still minor, no shift there either.
  • October 30 2012

    B.Smith says:

    Hi Bron or anyone who is in a position to know,

    How will the holding of gold effect the holders Taxation if and when the 'Basel' agreement becomes eccepted in early 2013.My understanding is that gold will become money does that mean it will still stay an asset or and become a stiff type of banknote?I look forward to any informed replies.

    regards ,B.Smith

  • October 30 2012

    Bron Suchecki says:

    B Smith,



    The Basel III changes will not make gold "money" or affect its taxation treatment. The changes will merely give banks which hold gold some relief from capital requirements.
  • February 06 2013

    Peter F says:

    Is it true that the government can use an act of parliament to confiscate gold held by Owners in the Perth Mint for an amount that they determine as far and equitable?
  • February 07 2013

    Bron Suchecki says:

    Peter,



    Your statement is a general one which applies to any country, as governments can create laws to achieve what they want. However, I believe you are referring to Part IV of the Banking Act 1959? If so, I covered that extensively in this personal blog post http://goldchat.blogspot.com.au/2008/11/australian-gold-confiscation.html
Comment on this post


   
 
 
 
 
   

Confirm
No
Yes